Only Murders in the Building Season Two Premiere Early Review

The following is a spoiler-free review of the first two episodes of Season 2 of Only Murders in the Building premiering Tuesday, June 28th on Disney+ Star and Hulu

For our review of the last episode of Only Murders in the Building, click here.

As the end of the first season saw our amateur team of podcasters on a high by solving the murder of Tim Kono and unbeknownst to them, another one, solving the mystery that had loomed over the Arconia, a cliffhanger made it clear that murders were not done with Charles, Oliver, and Mabel. The new victim, at least for now, was a nemesis in Bunny, the Arconia building manager. While the investigation still had some distance between Charles, Oliver, and Mabel and what they were investigating, things were a little different this time around as they found themselves in the middle of this one. The goal of this investigation, however, was more than just solving a murder but rather clearing their names. Their highly-publicized legal issues put them in the spotlight for better or worse therefore this season at least for now saw our three trying to maneuver around that cloud while going about living their lives and conducting their own investigation despite being persons of interest in Bunny’s murder.

The highlight of the series has been the dynamic of Charles, Oliver, and Mabel and this season is no different. Changing things up this time around, this season eliminates the main side characters from last season and allows them to stand out as individuals on top of their latest investigation. The extra dimension of the story may still be in its infancy but with that, the concern is how it affects the dynamic so hopefully the series doesn’t forget its importance. As mentioned, being in the spotlight afforded Charles, Oliver, and Mabel plenty of opportunities which they probably would not have had if not for that recent notoriety. The only question is whether or not they can ultimately succeed in spite of what loomed over them, primarily a Cinda Canning murder podcast investigating them in real time. That notoriety was a double-edged sword as our three tried to navigate their way through it all in the hopes of not ending up in prison by the end.

Charles, Oliver, and Mabel were a blast to watch once again with the addition of personal stakes alongside their latest investigation that led them towards the beginnings of the Arconia and its connections to the characters. The great banter was still there as the contrast in ages still made for some hilarious moments as their newfound fame meant an adjustment period for which they dealt with in their own ways. Meanwhile, many big guest stars are set to appear this season with a few of those appearing in the first two episodes. While welcome additions, the concern again is the distraction factor though with a lot of the same strong writing coming back, this doesn’t look to be an issue at least for now.

The best part of the Only Murders in the Building premiere, as was last season, was once again the performances of Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez who were compelling to watch as Charles, Oliver, and Mabel. Strong writing is one thing but their excellent chemistry is what truly brings it all to life. Though the season may have given them increased roles as individuals, they were still a delight to watch together as their character arcs from last season continue to grow. Beautifully treading the line between drama and comedy, the series is not only hilarious but also heartfelt. Martin Short’s Oliver is easily the MVP so far.

At the end of the day, Only Murders in the Building returns with a fun premiere that sees the series try to be more than just a simple mystery tale.

If you liked this, please read our other reviews here and don’t forget to follow us on Twitter or Instagram or like us on Facebook.

Keith Noakes

The EIC of the coincidentally-named keithlovesmovies.com. A Canadian who prefers to get out of the cold and into the warmth of a movie theatre.